American Jewish Committee (AJC), the global advocacy organization for the Jewish people, is offering guidance to university administrators on how to:
- prepare for the one-year anniversary of 10/7 on their campuses;
- proactively anticipate the needs of Jewish students;
- ensure there are safeguards and resources in place for them; and
- troubleshoot potential problems.
AJC recognizes that every campus is different and has distinctive needs. We are here to help you thoughtfully address the needs of your school. Please contact us to discuss how we can assist.
BACKGROUND
Monday, October 7, 2024 marks the one-year anniversary of the terror attacks in Israel in which nearly 1,200 people were brutally murdered by Hamas terrorists, who infiltrated the southern region of Israel in the early hours of the morning on the holy day of Shabbat and the Jewish holiday of Simchat Torah, storming communities and homes, and kidnapping and murdering innocent civilians, including babies, children, the disabled, and the elderly.
October 7th represents the deadliest terror attack in Israel’s history, in which not only Israeli Jews but also Muslims, Christians, Hindus, Buddhists, Israeli Arabs, and people from over 23 countries, including 32 Americans, were targeted and slaughtered.
October 7th also marks the most significant loss of Jewish life since the Holocaust and remains a painful open wound that may still directly impact Jewish students, faculty, and staff on your campus. At the time this document was written, 103 hostages were still being held in captivity by Hamas in Gaza, including 7 Americans.
BE ALERT AND AWARE
This year’s fall Jewish holiday season, which begins with the High Holiday of Rosh Hashanah on the evening of Wednesday, October 2nd, will be a challenging time for the Jewish community.
Be alert to the concerns of the Jewish community at a time when synagogues and other Jewish spaces are facing added risk and a need for increased security. It is now unfortunately routine for synagogues to be protected by armed guards, and it is important not to minimize the genuine security concerns that Jews face simply for attempting to live their lives openly as Jews. Administrators must ensure that the security needs of Jewish students are being met and that they remain safe and free from harassment when attending Jewish events or religious services on campus.
Be aware that many Jewish students have faced increasingly hostile rhetoric on their campuses because of their real or perceived connection to Israel and Zionism. Some of that rhetoric has included deeply problematic messaging about 10/7 that denies or minimizes the 10/7 attacks, or dehumanizes Israeli victims of 10/7 (“no innocent Israelis”; tearing down or vandalism of hostage posters; denial of sexual assault committed against Israelis). It has also included attempts to reframe the violence and terror of 10/7 as justified resistance, decolonization, or liberation. While inflammatory or hateful speech may be permitted according to your campus’ speech codes, language that minimizes or denies the impact of 10/7, or vilifies Israel and Zionism, or engages in victim-blaming for the atrocities committed on 10/7 will resonate painfully for many Jewish students, especially when such rhetoric appears in the spaces where they live and study.
Ensure that your campus has resources in place to address the wellbeing and mental health of Jewish students at this stressful time. Make those resources known to your entire student community, and make sure that all students, including Jews and Israelis, have unfettered access to the support services they need with no gatekeeping or litmus tests.
COMMUNICATE WITH CARE
In official and unofficial communications with students about the 10/7 anniversary, avoid using contested (i.e.: terms such as “genocide” or “occupation”) or vague language that may unwittingly distort your messaging or dilute your support for Jewish students at this difficult time.
- We encourage you to use accurate statistics whenever you describe the events of 10/7, which involved an unprovoked terrorist assault by Hamas on Israeli civilians that left 1,200 people dead, including women and children, and more than 250 hostages kidnapped to Gaza, mainly civilian, over 100 of whom are still being held hostage.
- There have been devastating civilian casualties on both sides of the Israel-Hamas war that followed from the 10/7 attacks; however, it can be painful and triggering to Jews when 10/7 victims are not given due recognition on their own terms, separately and distinctly from the casualties resulting from the ensuing war.
- Avoid incorrectly referring to those killed on 10/7 as victims of war, military incursion, or occupation. These designations misread the sequence of events that resulted in the deaths of innocent civilians in southern Israel, and can unwittingly promote the narrative that there are no innocent Israelis.
- For similar reasons, messaging about 10/7 should avoid comparative accounts of Palestinian deaths that ensued during the subsequent war. These deaths also deserve acknowledgment on their own terms, and should be addressed separately from messaging about the October 7th terror attacks.
If you have questions about how to navigate statements around 10/7, we are happy to be a resource for you and your staff. Contact us for guidance or to learn more.
ON CAMPUS PROGRAMS
For educational programming around 10/7, it is important to ensure that students and faculty are aware of the university’s rules and regulations regarding acceptable thresholds for educational events bearing the university’s name and logo. Teach-ins and other programming focused on 10/7 that receive official university approval should not become occasions for ideological indoctrination, ill-informed activism, the spread of misinformation, or shutting down dialogue around complex topics, even when they are painful. It is the university’s responsibility to ensure that educational programming focused on 10/7 and other topics be open to all participants regardless of their viewpoint, and offer a balance of perspectives that draws on recognized sources of expertise. Administrators also have a responsibility to shut down events that fail to obtain university clearance or adhere to the university’s standards for educational programming. Administrators can and should make use of their own voices to speak out in opposition to unbalanced programming or any programming that endorses or excuses violence.
BE MINDFUL
Understanding the impact of 10/7 on the Jewish community begins with being mindful of Jewish lived experiences and learning about the history of pogroms (anti-Jewish riots, destruction, violence, and murder). AJC offers expert-led educational programming on the long history of pogroms and their impact on Jewish collective memory. We also offer in-person educational programming for Resident Advisors, student activities supervisors, and leaders (both faculty and students) on navigating living together in a community, including guidance on fostering respect for Jewish history, traditions, and identity.
Consider learning more about the Jewish community by attending an in-person off-campus event this year. We can help! Contact us to learn about opportunities in your region.
